Nemesisghost wrote:Cybertraxs wrote:In researching I came across this:
http://www.digikey.com/product-detail/en/6127V1A360L.5FS/987-1393-ND/2620662 for $15 each US. for that price... well it would save a lot of time building them from scratch... and they would be consistent verse an uncertain outcome that each custom built hall Effect Sensor could deviate from the other depending on the magnet placement.. etc. would give different readings.
So maybe I'm missing something, but what would one of those Hall Effect Sensors offer over the 10k or 100k pots that we are using now? I get the other sensors that require a separate magnet mounted elsewhere, but these seem to just be a more expensive version of what we have now.
They are Hall Effect Potentiometers, something that is already manufactured, so we do not have to create something that can have different variables for the 3 points.
To quote: "Unlike potentiometers, Hall position sensors have no sliding electrical contacts to wear out, so they can offer higher reliability, particularly in corrosive environments. They show up in some models of commercial joysticks, as well as in after-market conversion kits for high end gaming hardware, such as the CubPilot Hall upgrade for the Thrustmaster HOTAS Cougar"
From my own experience, the less moving parts the longer the equipment will last.
To add these Hall Effect Sensors are much more quieter than normal potentiometers and have a ultra long-life, precision control solutions in harsh environments - grime, moisture, extreme temperature, or vibration (dither). Their Rotational Life have 10 million shaft revolutions with up to 8 oz sideload and are Mil spec. They are used in some models of commercial joysticks, as well as in after-market conversion kits for high end gaming hardware, such as the CubPilot Hall upgrade for the Thrustmaster HOTAS Cougar.
Personally, if I'm making a throttle, I'm going to want top quality parts.... if I can get Mil spec parts... I know they will last.
The Delta Throttle is a brilliant idea... we all have different experiences and expertise, so we are just helping taking it to the next level any way any of us can...